In a concerning development for democracy and human rights, Zimbabwe experienced a significant decline in 2023, according to the latest report from Human Rights Watch (HRW). The year was marked by a series of regressions across various domains, including electoral integrity, civil liberties, gender equality, and land rights. This downturn has been especially pronounced in the aftermath of the general polls held in August, leading to increased political uncertainty and unrest.
The Citizens’ Coalition for Change (CCC), the main opposition party, found itself at the center of controversy when its elected MPs were controversially recalled by a self-claimed secretary-general, Sengezo Tshabangu. This move underscored the tense political atmosphere pervading the country.
International observers, including the European Union Observer Mission and the Southern Africa Electoral Observer Mission (SEOM), were critical of the electoral process. They pointed out that the elections fell short of meeting the constitutional standards of Zimbabwe, the Electoral Act, and the Southern African Development Community (Sadc) Principles and Guidelines Governing Democratic Elections. Echoing these concerns, HRW’s 2024 world report highlighted an environment rife with threats, intimidation, repression, and violence against political opponents, severely compromising the electoral environment.
The impartiality of the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission came under scrutiny, and the government’s failure to investigate and prosecute abuses, primarily by supporters of the ruling Zanu PF party and state security forces, cemented a culture of impunity. This was particularly evident ahead of the elections, further eroding public trust in the electoral process.
The situation took a dramatic turn on election night when government security forces raided the offices of the Election Resource Centre (ERC) and the Zimbabwe Election Support Network (Zesn), arresting nearly 40 staff and volunteers. This raid effectively prevented an independent verification of the official results, casting further doubts on the electoral integrity.
Despite these glaring challenges, President Mnangagwa’s inauguration was attended by a few regional leaders, indicating a lukewarm regional reaction to the election’s outcome. The government did not relent in its crackdown on civil society, revoking the registration of 291 non-governmental and civil society organizations for alleged non-compliance with the Private Voluntary Organisations Act.
The introduction of repressive laws, such as the amendment to the Private Voluntary Organisations (PVO) Act and the so-called “Patriotic Bill,” posed significant threats to freedom of association and expression. These laws, criticized for their vagueness and potential for abuse, undermined the legitimate activities of those asserting their rights.
Arbitrary arrests and the weaponization of the law against critics of the government persisted. Opposition figures, including Job Sikhala, were subjected to extended pre-trial detentions, while others faced charges that appeared more aimed at silencing dissent than enforcing justice.
The abduction, torture, and sexual assault of opposition MP Joana Mamombe and activists Netsai Marova and Cecillia Chimbiri, who were subsequently charged for staging their own kidnapping, exemplify the government’s severe approach to opposition and criticism.
Zimbabwe’s human rights landscape in 2023 offers a grim view of a nation struggling with political instability, suppression of dissent, and the erosion of democratic freedoms. The international community’s reaction, together with domestic calls for justice and reform, is crucial in confronting these issues. As Zimbabwe looks to the future, the imperative for accountability, transparency, and the upholding of human rights is more pressing than ever in the pursuit of lasting peace and democracy.
About The Author
This report serves as an urgent call to the international community and regional leaders to not stand by as democratic principles are eroded in Zimbabwe. The detailed account of electoral malpractices, intimidation, and the crackdown on freedom of expression and association underscores the need for a concerted effort to support Zimbabweans in their quest for justice and democratic governance. Silence and inaction only embolden repressive regimes.
The heavy reliance on Western observers and Human Rights Watch for critiquing Zimbabwe’s elections and human rights situation feels biased. This perspective often ignores the sovereignty of African nations and their contextual challenges. It’s important to question whether these international standards are always applicable or fair, considering the West’s own troubled history with democracy and human rights. Good article but Westernized.